Why Seller Feedback Is a Critical Sales Tool in 2025
Seller feedback directly affects your account health, Buy Box eligibility, and visibility. In 2025, Amazon:
- Introduced a star-only feedback system, reducing feedback context and lowering your ability to appeal negative ratings (Seller Forums, The Sun).
- Continues to rely on feedback as a key component of performance metrics like Order Defect Rate, which influences account standing and Buy Box competition (EcomEngine, Adbrew).
Without written feedback, sellers lose clarity on customer complaints. Amazon has also disabled appeals for star-only feedback in the Feedback Manager (Seller Forums).
Handling feedback the right way is now more urgent.
Step 1: Know What Changed in 2025
- Star-only feedback is now permitted, meaning Amazon customers can rate you with stars without adding text comments (Seller Forums, The Sun).
- Appeal options are limited. Written feedback can be appealed through the Feedback Manager, but star-only ratings cannot unless flagged as abusive or violating Amazon rules.
- Feedback still matters. Star-only ratings are now part of your buyer experience score, which influences Buy Box and search placement (EcomEngine, Adbrew).
Step 2: Real-World Impact of Feedback Shifts
- Sellers increasingly express frustration: “How can we respond or improve when a negative rating comes with no explanation?” (Seller Forums, The Sun)
- Star-only ratings scramble your understanding of issues. Was it late delivery, product mismatch, or FBA logistics? Without context, you lose the opportunity to act (The Sun).
- Feedback remains integral. Negative scores drag down Buy Box chances and the erosion of customer trust can directly reduce conversions (Adbrew).
Step 3: What You Can Do to Stay Protected
Here’s your proactive checklist:
- Monitor Feedback Closely
Use Seller Central’s Feedback Manager daily to spot star-only ratings as they appear (EcomEngine). - Respond Swiftly to Every Low-Rating
Even without text, act on star-only negative feedback. Contact Amazon through “Report a violation” if it’s unjust or abusive (Seller Forums). - Ramp Up Positive Feedback via Approved Channels
Use Amazon’s “Request a Review” button or approved automation tools to invite feedback post-delivery (eDesk, EcomEngine). - Provide Excellent Service Across the Board
Fast shipping, accurate listings, and prompt support form the backbone of good feedback (EcomEngine, Adbrew). - Train Your Team
Everyone handling customer service, whether VAs, agents, or fulfillment staff, needs to understand feedback’s impact and follow-up protocols. - Use Customer Service as Prevention
The best way to reduce negative feedback is to preempt it. Address issues before they convert into low star ratings.
Core Strategies in Brief
Strategy
Monitor daily
Report unjust feedback
Request reviews compliantly
Train your team
Always be proactive
Why It Matters
Early detection protects your metrics
It’s your only appeal path with no text
Builds a positive buffer in feedback score
Prevents mistakes that lead to bad feedback
Prevention works better than reaction
Don’t Let Star-Only Feedback Cut Your Sales
Prefer to Listen Instead?
Tune into our podcast Amazon TL;DR: eGrowth Partners News Insights for Sellers for a 10-minute breakdown on adapting to the star-only feedback era and preserving your sales engine.
Listen on:
